Consistency Rule Calculator: Prop Firm Rules Compared
One formula covers every prop firm’s best-day rule. Here is how to work it out by hand, a ready-made table for common percentages, and what each firm actually uses.
Last updated 31 Oct 2026A prop firm consistency rule limits how much of your profit can come from your single best day. The percentage changes from firm to firm, from 20% to 60%, and so does the stage it applies to: some firms check it before you pass the evaluation, others only before a payout on the funded account. The arithmetic behind it is always the same, so once you know the formula you can act as your own consistency rule calculator for any firm. This guide shows the formula, a table you can read your numbers from, and the current rules at the best-known futures firms.
Rules read on 31 Oct 2026 from each firm’s own help center: Topstep (Consistency at Topstep, Express Funded Account Parameters), Take Profit Trader (Be Consistent), Tradeify (Consistency Rule, Essential Trading Rules Overview) and Lucid Trading (each plan’s consistency, evaluation and payout articles). Rules for Alpha Futures, Bulenox, Earn2Trade, FundedNext Futures, E8 Markets, FundingPips and The5ers come from the official pages listed on their EvalSaver rules pages. Firms change these rules often, so check the firm’s help center before you buy.
The consistency rule formula
Every firm writes it slightly differently, but it comes down to one division: best day ÷ total profit = consistency percentage. Topstep calls it Best Day Profit ÷ Total Profit; Take Profit Trader writes Highest profit day ÷ Net P/L; Lucid uses Largest Single Day Profit ÷ Account Profit. If your best day is $900 and your total profit is $3,000, your consistency is 30%.
Turn the formula around and you get the three numbers you actually need while trading:
- Largest best day that still lets you pass on target = profit target × percentage. A $3,000 target at 40% allows a $1,200 best day.
- Total profit you need after a big day = best day ÷ percentage. A $1,500 day at 40% means $1,500 ÷ 0.40 = $3,750 in total.
- Extra profit still to make = total needed − profit you have now. With $3,100 made, that $1,500 day leaves $650 to go, on days smaller than $1,500.
The fourth number traders forget is the minimum number of winning days. At 50% or more you can pass in two days; at 40% you need at least three, because two days can never both be under 40% of their sum; at 30% four, and at 20% five. Where a firm says strictly below 50%, as Take Profit Trader does, two equal days come out at exactly 50% and don’t qualify, so plan for a third.
Consistency rule calculator table
Read your numbers from this table instead of dividing by hand. It uses a $3,000 target, the most common 50K target in futures, and shows what a $1,500 best day does to it.
| Rule | Best day for an on-target pass | Total needed after a $1,500 day | Fewest winning days |
|---|---|---|---|
| 60% | $1,800 | $3,000 (target holds) | 2 |
| 55% | $1,650 | $3,000 (target holds) | 2 |
| 50% | $1,500 | $3,000 | 2 |
| 40% | $1,200 | $3,750 | 3 |
| 35% | $1,050 | $4,286 | 3 |
| 30% | $900 | $5,000 | 4 |
| 20% | $600 | $7,500 | 5 |
For another target, multiply the target by the percentage for the best-day column, and divide your own best day by the percentage for the second column. On a 100K with a $6,000 target and a 40% rule, the largest best day is $2,400, and a $3,000 day pushes the total you need to $7,500.
Best day rule by firm
These are the consistency rules at the firms traders search for most, and at the futures firms where we have an official code. “None” means the official pages we read state there is no consistency percentage at that stage.
| Firm and plan | Evaluation | Funded account (before a payout) |
|---|---|---|
| Topstep | 55% Consistency Target | 40% on the Consistency payout path; none on Standard |
| Take Profit Trader | Below 50%, 3 trading days minimum | No separate rule found on the pages we read |
| Tradeify Advanced / Growth | Not stated in the articles read | 35% |
| Tradeify Lightning | Not covered in the articles read | 20% (see below) |
| Lucid LucidFlex | 40% (50% with an add-on) | None |
| Lucid LucidPro | None | 40% |
| Lucid LucidDirect | No evaluation | 20% |
| Alpha Futures Standard / Advanced | 50% / 40% | 40% / none |
| Earn2Trade | 30% | None |
| Bulenox Qualification | None | 40% on Master Account payouts |
| FundedNext Futures Flex / Rapid | 40% / none | None / 40% (Rapid Pro) |
Two patterns stand out. Firms that let you pass in one day usually move the rule to the funded account, as LucidPro, Bulenox and FundedNext Futures Rapid do. And firms with no rule on the funded account usually check it in the evaluation instead, like LucidFlex and Earn2Trade. Among the plans in this table, only FundedNext Futures’ Rapid Daily journey has none at either stage.
30%, 40% and 50% consistency rules in practice
The percentage looks like a small detail, but it changes how many days you need and how one lucky session affects you.
- 30% consistency rule (Earn2Trade’s evaluation): on a $3,000 target, no day above $900. A single $1,500 day means $5,000 of total profit, two thirds more than the target.
- 40% consistency rule (LucidFlex evaluation, Topstep’s Consistency payout path, Bulenox and LucidPro payouts): the most common figure. A $3,000 goal fits a $1,200 best day and needs at least three winning days.
- 50% consistency rule (Alpha Futures Standard, Take Profit Trader’s Test, LucidDaily): two good days can be enough, though at Take Profit Trader the line is strictly below 50% and the Test also needs 3 trading days.
- 20% rule (LucidDirect and Tradeify Lightning funded accounts): the strictest you will find. On a $3,000 payout goal the best day can’t exceed $600, so it suits traders who already make small, regular gains. Tradeify’s article also lists 25% for a Lightning account’s second payout and 30% after that, while its overview gives a flat 20%, so confirm with Tradeify.
What happens when you break it
At every firm in the table above, breaking the consistency rule doesn’t close or fail the account. You keep trading until the ratio falls back under the line, and the only way to get there is more profit on other days. Take Profit Trader’s own example: on a 50K Test with a $3,000 goal, a $2,000 first day and $1,100 after it is 65%. Total profit has to reach $4,001 before $2,000 is below half of it, which is $901 more.
Losses make it worse, not better. A losing day lowers your total profit but leaves your best day where it is, so the percentage goes up. Topstep says so directly: losses don’t reset your best day. On funded accounts the count usually restarts after each approved payout (Topstep, Tradeify, Lucid and Alpha Futures all reset it), which means every payout cycle is checked on its own.
Common mistakes
- Doubling size after a good start. The bigger the second day, the bigger the best day you have to dilute.
- Assuming the evaluation rule carries over. Alpha Futures, Lucid and FundedNext Futures all use a different percentage, or none, once you’re funded.
- Trading the same day to fix it. Profit made later in the same session adds to that day, so the ratio doesn’t improve. Spread the extra over separate sessions.
- Forgetting the other payout conditions. Winning-day counts, minimum profit, buffers and payout caps still apply when your consistency is fine.
- Reading the wrong version. Lucid’s LucidPro rule moved from 35% to 40% for accounts bought or reset from 28 Nov 2025, and Topstep’s Combine target moved from 50% to 55%. Use the date on the help center article.
Firm-by-firm detail: the Topstep consistency rule, the Alpha Futures consistency rule and the Lucid Trading consistency rule have their own guides with worked examples per plan. A consistency rule only matters while the account is open, so check the drawdown too: our static vs trailing drawdown guide explains how each type closes accounts.
Firms with similar rules and an EvalSaver code
We don’t have a code with Topstep, Take Profit Trader, Tradeify or Lucid. If you are comparing rules, these firms have an official EvalSaver code: Alpha Futures has plans with 50%, 40% or no rule in the evaluation; Earn2Trade uses 30% in the evaluation and none once funded; Bulenox has none in the Qualification; FundedNext Futures Rapid has none in the challenge. On the forex side, E8 Markets, FundingPips and The5ers use best-day or best-trade rules on some plans (35% on E8 Signature payouts, 15% on FundingPips Zero, 40% per trade at The5ers Futures).
FAQ
Divide your best day by your total profit. If the result is above the firm’s limit, divide your best day by the limit to get the total profit you need: a $1,500 best day under a 40% rule needs $3,750 in total.
No single day can be more than 40% of your total profit. On a $3,000 target the largest best day is $1,200, and you need at least three winning days.
At Topstep, Take Profit Trader, Tradeify, Lucid, Alpha Futures and the other firms in this guide, no. You keep trading until your best day is back under the limit, as long as you respect the loss limits.
Some plans skip it at one stage: LucidPro, Bulenox and FundedNext Futures Rapid have none in the evaluation, while LucidFlex, Earn2Trade and FundedNext Futures Flex have none on the funded account. Check both stages before you buy.
No. A loss lowers your total profit and leaves your best day unchanged, so your percentage rises. Only profit on other days brings it down.